Figure (taxo): Sorcière

  • Magical Feminism: The Manifestation and Evolution of the Witch Under the Male Gaze

    « Since her fabrication, the Witch has been suffocated by the masculine voice and mode. Beginning with the witch-hunts, her social narrative has been completely dictated by men. All predicating texts were written by men, for men to use against women. From Macbeth to the King James Bible, from Glinda to Galinda, from Carrie to Sue, and from Myrtle to Madison, men have defined, silenced, and appropriated Witches’ voices in order to maintain social hegemony and hierarchy – man’s supremacy over women. Very rarely has a woman’s witchy voice been heard when set against overpowering patriarchal domination. While women have written Witches in the shadows, it is the male voice that has historically defined her as a threat to society, i.e., patriarchy. Women critics such as Matilda Joslyn Gage have defended the Witch as a source of Female power and an obvious display of brutal patriarchal persecution, but the literary Witch and her accompanying images that define public perception remain dominated by men, trapping her in a cyclical fallacy of female autonomy, fabricated by men.

    Through a Feminist theory of male gaze with New Historicism approach, this thesis will examine the manifestation and evolution of the Witch, starting with the Witch’s origin and connection to birth and death through Lilith. Next, it will provide an overview of the Witch in literary and visual mediums during European witchcraze in order to show its influence on William Shakespeare’s Macbeth, the King James Bible, and Christian rhetoric, codifying the social perception of Witches’ – and thereby all women’s – inherent wickedness. Turning to the first modern Feminist wave, Matilda Josyln Gage’s treatise Women, Church, and State, brings forward and defends the Witch as an intelligently educated women who threatened the patriarchy by living outside the bounds of male influence and paints Witches as victims of masculine fear. Her treatise proposed an image of a kind, intelligent Witch, persecuted and murdered for her female intelligence. The legacy of Gage’s good Witch lives through her son-in-law’s children’s book The Wonderful Land of Oz. The words asked by the Good Witch of the North upon Dorothy’s arrival opened the door to represent women with power and magic as beings of goodness. However, L. Frank Baum’s lasting legacy is the Wicked Witch of the West, further solidified by Margaret Hamilton’s iconic performance on screen. In the second Feminist wave, this thesis will explore the use of Exodus in Carrie to show how the King James Bible is still being used to justify and persecute women as Witches out of fear and hate. In the third Feminist wave, the Wicked Witch of the West is reborn through Gregory Maguire’s Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West, which explores the backstory and motivations of the Wicked Witch, exploring both her obsession with her sister’s shoes and her green hue. These Witches, echoes of the images of Witches throughout history, are further examples of the Witch under the male gaze. Ushering in the fourth Feminist wave, Witches have finally broken through patriarchal male gaze and limitations, opening new possibilities for a thoroughly Feminine literary structure. Ariel Gore’s We Were Witches is an extraordinary exemplar of the potential literary creation that happens when a Witch takes hold and fully claims her witchy power and forges an entirely new, magical literary structure – defining the Witch as a figure of women’s fortitude, love, and survival. » [Résumé]

  • Queering Witches: A Queer Feminist Exploration of Witches in Media

    « This thesis is an exploration of witches, as depicted in entertainment media. “Queering Witches: A Queer Feminist Exploration of Witches in Media” analyzes the way history has contributed to the reinforcement of stereotypes about witches using queer theory and feminist analysis. “Queering Witches” also offers a broad view of the intersectionality inherent to the way witches are presented in media, specifically delving into definitions of witches, Satanists, witches of color, and the intersection of witches and the queer/LGBTQIA+ community. The introduction of feminist analysis and queer theory emphasizes the way stereotypes about witches and performance of power have been demonized by society in much the same way as the performance of gender and sexuality have been demonized. » [Résumé]

  • Poisoner, Shapeshifter, Adulteress, Thief: Legends and Images of Witchcraft in Finnmark and Gotland

    « This dissertation concerns legends of witches from fifteenth-, sixteenth-, and seventeenth-century Scandinavia. My aim is to demonstrate that the figure of the witch was deeply meaningful and spoke in the symbolic language of legends to anxieties surrounding womanhood, motherhood, and the social power of women to construct and maintain communities. In particular, I investigate several productive motifs and motif-complexes, including “edible witchcraft,” shapeshifting, and magical milk-theft, showing how these tropes inform the construction of the witch figure as an anti-neighbor, anti-human, anti-wife, and anti-mother. I focus on how witchcraft legends functioned especially in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries in two sites that each offer different types of sources for these legends: Finnmark, Norway’s northernmost province, and Gotland, an island in the Baltic Sea that has since 1645 been a province of Sweden, and which previously was part of the Danish empire (as was the whole of Norway, from the sixteenth century until 1814). In Finnmark, I focus on the documentation of a series of witch trials that occurred over the course of the seventeenth century, Norway’s worst outbreak of witch trials and on par, in terms of execution ratios, with the worst in Continental Europe during the whole period of witch trials (roughly the 1420s to 1700). On Gotland, I focus on visual evidence: church murals, dating to the late fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries, that feature a legendary character known in English as the “milk-stealing witch” (in Swedish she is instead more typically called tjuvmjölkande kvinnan, ‘the milk-stealing woman’). I draw also on legends recorded by folklorists in later centuries, especially, in the case of Gotland, on the legends and beliefs collected in the nineteenth century on the island by the enterprising P. A. Säve. I do not seek to present these sites as a comparison, but rather seek to demonstrate how the witch emerged in localized legends, at different times and in different genres, and yet drew on common tropes and motifs to explore similar themes of gender and social power. » [Résumé]

  • Casting a Spell on Feminism: A Rhetorical Analysis of Sabrina Spellman and the Dialectic of Feminist Liberation and Patriarchal Control

    « Witches have long captivated the public’s imagination as symbols of both the oppression and liberation of women. This tension between control and liberation is precisely why the witch is such a powerful symbol for feminism. This thesis explores how gendered representations of witches in popular culture index the status/strength/struggles of feminism at any given time. This thesis is a feminist rhetorical analysis of one witch in particular: Sabrina Spellman. Originally a 1962 Archie comic character, then the 1996 live-action series Sabrina the Teenage Witch starring Melissa Joan Hart, Sabrina returned again in the 2018 Netflix reboot the Chilling Adventures of Sabrina staring Kiernan Shipka. Due to Sabrina’s rich history and persistence, she serves as a reflection of feminism at different points in time. This thesis explores the rhetorical strategies through which Sabrina is depicted as a symbol for feminist liberation, but also the ways patriarchal control is enforced in each of these texts to limit her power. » [Résumé]

  • Night of the Witch: Alternative Spirituality, Identity and Media

    « This thesis works to understand the relationships witches and conjurors have with the film and television depictions of them. Employing the method of film critique, I argue that the witch stands as a cultural symbol in the US of women and femmes with power, and that their stories serve as lessons to these populations about what it means to be an acceptable woman or femme, while simultaneously creating and perpetuating stereotypes of magic practitioners. Then, using the combination of hashtag ethnography, in-person and video interviewing and internet surveys, I argue that #witchblr and #witchesofcolor, as well as the space of an interview with another practitioner, serves as a counterspace where the counternarratives against oppression, of resistance, and of personal identity work can take place. I connect the language practitioners use to describe themselves and witches and conjurors in film and television to the embracing and distancing marginalized communities engage in when crafting their identities around stereotyped notions of their group, and argue for the need for a simpler, softer, more diverse witchcraft in United States film and television. » [Résumé]

  • Façonner la vérité : du maître à la sorcière

    « Cette recherche présente une critique politique actuelle de l’épistémologie occidentale contemporaine héritière de Hegel et de Nietzsche à travers la critique féministe du point de vue situé et de la théorie du Care. Sous la prémisse commune d’un lien fondateur réciproque entre l’expérience et la connaissance, comment peut-on comprendre le dépassement de la métaphysique et le dépassement de l’oppression comme deux faces d’un même enjeu? La critique féministe des systèmes de domination et la découverte philosophique de l’absence de fondements métaphysiques absolus pour la connaissance apparaissent comme deux questions qui se rejoignent. L’oppression fonctionne avec la métaphysique parce qu’il s’agit de la stratégie employée par une part de l’humanité pour tenter d’abolir la réalité de la souffrance en effaçant l’existence qui la connaît puisqu’elle la subit et la soulage. L’abolition de l’oppression ne vise pas seulement à libérer les opprimé-e-s, mais à libérer tout le monde de la peur en acceptant l’instabilité, la souffrance et la mort comme part de l’existence que nous créons et comme élément du bien-être que nous construisons. Face à la question du dépassement de la métaphysique, une telle compréhension du phénomène de l’oppression répond au gouffre laissé par la perte des absolus. Le dépassement de la métaphysique ne nous laisse plus devant un vide froid et désespéré si nous réhabilitons en nous-mêmes la vie sensible capable de bien-être et de souffrance, de guérison et de transformation. » [Résumé]

  • Bewitching the Blame: the Crucible’s Legacy of Appropriation and Sexual Shame in Popular Culture

    « In The Crucible Arthur Miller uses tropes of female characters, Abigail and Tituba, to tell a story of male heroism. In the process, he dismisses and appropriates the true stories of women who suffered during the Salem witch trials for his own political and personal gain. In this thesis, I argue that Miller’s appropriation and sexualization of women continues into contemporary popular culture depictions of the Salem witch trials including the movie adaptation of The Crucible and the television shows Salem and American Horror Story: Coven. These depictions appropriate and sexualize women’s stories in order to fulfill the male gaze. This thesis also explores how three contemporary women playwrights are writing new plays that address the sexism of Arthur Miller, show how The Crucible perpetuates abuse, and encourage women to confront sexism by creating their own works about the Salem trials. These plays are Abigail by Sarah Tuft, John Proctor is the Villain by Kimberly Belflower, and Becky Nurse of Salem by Sarah Ruhl. Finally, I argue that in order to have a true feminist redemption of the Salem witch trials in popular culture, there must be more creative and scholarly analysis of Tituba, a woman of color who has been most silenced in these depictions. » [Résumé]

  • Diagnosing Witchery: Early Modern Medical Discourses, Public Health, and the Gendered Body in the Seventeenth Century English Witch-Panics

    « This research examines the nexus of witchcraft and early modern healthcare. It draws on witchcraft studies and history of medicine to frame witchcraft as a public health crisis originating in, and investigated through, misogynistic medical ideologies. This research began primarily as an attempt to answer lingering questions of gender discrepancy in predominance of female executions. By examining the witch-panics of the 1640s through early modern medical discourses, this thesis contributes to understanding the physiological origins of witchcraft. Its findings provide the intersection of medical history and the gendered body as a cohesive framework for the dominant discourses in early modern English witchcraft scholarship. It engages with traditional historiographical narratives of witchcraft largely dominated by socio-economic and gender dynamics of daily life in a tumultuous period of English history. It utilizes sources from medical literature, witchcraft treatises, pamphlet testimony records, statistical data, as well as the diaries and reports of early modern contemporaries. The study demonstrates the witch-panics possessed an emphatically environmental dimension. This consisted of century-long concerns over public health instigated by humanity’s sins: worsening mortality crises, rampant endemic diseases, violent religious conflicts, and crop failures. These disasters implicated human sin at the root of these catastrophes. By interrogating the physiological weaknesses characterizing the female body, this work situates witches as covert carriers of sin and harbingers of illness. This understanding shaped all levels of English witchcraft investigation within notions of public health and disease. Witchcraft is examined vis-à-vis burgeoning English public health discourses, the medicalized misogyny informing the witch-figure in popular European culture, and the investigative and protective roles of the body in East Anglian witch investigations. » [Résumé]

  • Caliban et la sorcière. Femmes, corps et accumulation

    « Militante féministe radicale et universitaire, l’auteure revisite ce moment de l’histoire qu’est la transition entre le féodalisme et le capitalisme en y introduisant la perspective de l’histoire des femmes. Elle invite à réfléchir aux rapports d’exploitation et de domination alors que la privatisation des biens autrefois collectifs transforme les rapports de travail et les relations de genre. » (Résumé de l’éditeur)

  • « Because she would not be governed » : Medieval women, power, and the politicization of witchcraft

    « Since the mid-twentieth century, scholarship on European witchcraft has proved critical in understanding the relationship between gender, sexuality, and power in pre-modern Western society. For medieval and early modern people, accusations of heresy and witchcraft served to reinstate control over elements of society that were perceived as dangerous or dissident to the established order. While advances in the study of witchcraft have greatly informed the fields of history and anthropology, such scholarship has up until this point largely focused on witch hunts targeting women of the lower classes. Further study concerning the use of witchcraft charges as a political tool aimed at socially prominent women is needed to better inform scholarly understanding of the full breadth of the European witch craze. This thesis will specifically examine a multitude of cases spanning the early Middle Ages through the early modern period, roughly the fifth through eighteenth centuries, involving women in positions of social visibility and power, who were attacked with witchcraft accusations as a means of removing them from a seemingly unnatural gender role.

    Methodology or Procedures:

    This thesis utilizes a diverse range of medieval documents, especially witchcraft treatises, as a means of exploring the evolution of European witchcraft throughout the medieval period, culminating in the late medieval feminization of the institution of witchcraft. In order to establish politically motivated witchcraft charges against powerful women as a repeating pattern throughout medieval and early modern history, this study assumes a sweeping perspective, taking note of similar cases occurred both chronologically and geographically separate from one another. Subsequently, the source material upon which this thesis relies is quite diverse. Infamous inquisitors’ guides such as the Formicarius by Johannes Nider and the Malleus Maleficarum by Kramer and Sprenger provide the theoretical foundation upon which such witchcraft charges were built, and similarly allow me to explain the belief system in place that allowed witchcraft accusations against prominent women to succeed.

    Moving on from this foundational literature, this study explores a variety of primary sources documenting specific instances of witchcraft accusations leveled at socially influential women. These will include, to name a few, the claims of witchcraft aimed at the Anglo-Saxon Queen Ælfthryth in the twelfth-century chronicle Liber Eilensis, the recording of the sorcery trial of Dame Alice Kyteler in fourteenth-century Ireland, and the court proceedings for treason and witchcraft brought against Joan of Arc in fifteenth-century Burgundy and Queen Anne Boleyn in 1530s England. Examining the implications of witchcraft accusations on powerful women will broaden and bolster scholarship on the European witchcraft movement by illustrating both how these cases fit into the larger fabric of medieval society, and how they maintained or impacted the social hierarchy and its prescribed gender roles.

    Findings:

    This study illustrates a pattern of politically motivated witchcraft accusations throughout the medieval and early modern period informed by a single, ever-expanding lexicon supporting the idea of feminized witchcraft. Unlike much previous scholarship on European witchcraft, this thesis demonstrates that socially prominent women, for a myriad of reasons ranging from the scrutiny given to their sexual conduct to their contested foothold in both the domestic and public spheres, were just as susceptible to accusations of sorcery and witchcraft as their lower-class counterparts. The case studies presented here also demonstrate a pattern of naming women as witches in an attempt to delegitimize their agency in the male-dominated arenas of governance, religion, warfare, and commerce. Because this method successfully defamed and destroyed numerous powerful women throughout the Middle Ages, the inherent characteristics of the witch became intertwined with unrestrained women, creating an environment that allowed political detractors to slander women for witch-like crimes, without ever invoking that particular label. This finding demands further study on the relationship between powerful women and claims of deviant behavior as an essential aspect of pre-modern women’s social history. » [Résumé]